Plastic Bins vs. Cardboard Boxes: What’s Best for Storage?

When you gather your packing supplies for self storage, you’ll come across an important decision: do you get cardboard boxes or plastic bins? Whether you need large storage bins or storage boxes with lids, each type has situations where it works best.
Use this guide from Overflow Garage to know the differences, advantages, and drawbacks of using cardboard boxes and plastic bins.
Cardboard vs. Plastic Storage Bins
Gathering all your packing materials ahead of time is one of the best tips you can get. Obtaining the right type of bin is another important part of storage preparation. Both styles of containers have their advantages and disadvantages. We’ll guide you through the pros and cons of cardboard and plastic bins.
Pros of Plastic Storage Bins
- More durable
- Better as stackable storage bins
- Protects against pests
- Often see-through
- Easy to clean
Cons of Plastic Storage Bins
- Can trap moisture more easily
- Often bulkier
- More expensive
- Limited customization
- Not made for extreme heat or cold
Pros of Cardboard Bins for Storage
- Cost-effective
- Collapsible
- Recyclable
- Lightweight and easy to handle
- Customizable
Cons of Cardboard Bins for Storage
- Less durable
- Not suitable for heavy items
- Sensitive to moisture
- Does not shield well against dust
- Requires assembly
When To Use Plastic Bins for Storage
Since durability and stackability are some of the many benefits of plastic bins, the best use of these containers is for long-term storage and shielding sensitive items from the elements.
Many plastic bins will come with sealable lids to help keep dust, pests, and debris out. Plastic bins are also a better solution for heavier or larger items, though remember not to overpack your boxes. It’s much easier to lift a bin that isn’t filled to the brim with heavy supplies or decorations.
When To Use Cardboard Bins for Storage
Cardboard containers are ideal for short-term storage solutions, such as moving. Cardboard boxes are best used with the impression that they will be unpacked in the not-too-distant future. Opting for short-term cardboard box storage can yield savings and help optimize every square inch of space compared to the bulkier plastic containers.
How To Store Cardboard Boxes
Cardboard boxes last longer when stored in a cool, dry self storage unit. For an additional shield for items sensitive to extreme heat or rain, consider renting climate-controlled storage.
Read our packing tips page for more beneficial advice.
Store Your Boxes and Bins at Overflow Garage Today
Make storing your belongings easy with Overflow Garage. Choose from a wide range of small, medium, and large storage units sized to fit your boxes and bins at our storage facilities in Texas and Oklahoma.
Contact us online or find your nearest Overflow Garage storage facility to start your storage journey today!